@@ -33,7 +33,10 @@ Emails were sent to a few [IEEE Societies and Technical Councils](https://docs.g
...
@@ -33,7 +33,10 @@ Emails were sent to a few [IEEE Societies and Technical Councils](https://docs.g
#### 3. General discussion:
#### 3. General discussion:
Finally, the following topics were discussed:
Finally, the following topics were discussed:
-**[\[ACTION ITEM\]](https://opensource.ieee.org/community/peer-review/admin/-/issues/21)** all committee members are asked to help clarify "the context of open source design" at IEEE: what exactly is that context? Linked to publication? Hosting of Open Research? Standards related? Project hosting?
-**[\[ACTION ITEM\]](https://opensource.ieee.org/community/peer-review/admin/-/issues/21)** all committee members are asked to help clarify "the context of open source design" at IEEE: what exactly is that context? Linked to publication? Hosting of Open Research? Standards related? Project hosting?
-**[\[ACTION ITEM\]](https://opensource.ieee.org/community/peer-review/admin/-/issues/21)** there is a need to define the value proposition that peer-review adds to open source designs. One way to illustrate the value proposition is described in this way:
-**[\[ACTION ITEM\]](https://opensource.ieee.org/community/peer-review/admin/-/issues/21)** there is a need to define the value proposition that peer-review adds to open source designs. One way to describe the value proposition was shared on :
> if two projects start from the same source files, by submitting one of them to planned review(s) by a group of subject-matter-experts (i.e. peers): it is reasonable to expect that through this process the design would gain a higher level of quality than the project that did not use peer-review.
* : same design but one with peer-review should have more intrinsic value
* : same design but one with peer-review should have more intrinsic value
f. add the definition what an "official IEEE open source project is" and how this pee-review provides value to that specific type of project
f. add the definition what an "official IEEE open source project is" and how this pee-review provides value to that specific type of project
...
@@ -49,9 +52,9 @@ Finally, the following topics were discussed:
...
@@ -49,9 +52,9 @@ Finally, the following topics were discussed:
> Written with [StackEdit](https://stackedit.io/).
> Written with [StackEdit](https://stackedit.io/).
